Thursday, 11 May 2017

TV And Mental Health: The Good The Bad And The Ugly

TV And Mental Health: The Good The Bad And The Ugly depression OCD eastenders the big bang theory obessive complsuive cleaners super size vs super skinny TV UK blogger the worst mental illness

I like watching TV, however, if there is one thing I don't like its bad representation. Bad representation of anything, whether that be LGBT+ rights, acknowledging people of colour and of course mental illness. TV shows are something which can either hit the nail on the end when it comes to representing a mental illness or completely get it wrong and end up offending quite a few people, myself included.

It's not all doom and gloom though, alongside the awful shows which made a complete cock up and didn't present mental illness well at all, there are a few who do an excellent job! Hooray! I'll admit there isn't that many, well not that I'm aware of. I'm always up for discovering new shows though so do hit me up with your suggestions. I still think it's good to acknowledge them though. It's incredibly important to bring mental illness into mainstream media but more importantly present it accurately. 

I don't think I would be alone in saying that I would rather have a mental illness not mentioned at all in TV shows then presented really badly. Whether that be suggesting that those who are mentally ill are all criminals and murders or if you have OCD you just like things neat and tidy. This does more damage than good, to be frank. I would rather not have it at all, but unfortunately, it does exist. There's not much I can do expect to call out the bad shows and hope they never get recommissioned. As always I would love to know your thoughts on any of the TV shows mentioned in this post, do you agree or disagree? Let me know in the comments!


Let's start with the positives yeah?


THE GOOD 


The Big Bang Theory 

Okay so I know not everyone likes how obsessive compulsive disorder is portrayed in this show, but I actually don't mind it. Sheldon the main character displays a lot of OCD characteristics although I don't think it's ever explicitly stated that he does or doesn't have the illness in any of the series'. Sheldon's OCD centres around a need for closure. Whenever he knocks on the door, he has to knock three times, say the person's name and repeat till they answer. If they answer without him finishing he will still have to continue the compulsion. 

Sheldon also expresses a hatred for germs. If he drinks from another person's glass, he over reacts and lists all the illnesses he is going to get. He also refuses to touch door handles in public places, e.g., the hospital. It's hard to comment if this really is OCD or just a fear of germs as no intrusive thoughts are ever mentioned. That being said, I don't think the Big Bang theory adds to the stigma around OCD and actually portrays it quite well. I have to admit I do love this show, the theme tune is definitely not my ringtone or anything...

Eastenders 

Back in the day probably when I was 11-13 years old I used to watch Eastenders religiously. Honestly, I have no idea why and I wish I kind of didn't especially as I was so young, but I did, and I can't reverse the past. However, a particular storyline that does stick in my mind is Stacey and Jean's bipolar storyline. I remember very clearly watching Stacey in denial about her illness, acting irrationally and confused. 

She starts claiming that she can see her baby. There are voices in her head, and the baby is following her around. The people around her don't understand, they think she is crazy and completely off the rails. Little do they know she's suffering from a complex mental illness. A particular scene that is vivid in my memory is when Stacey was sectioned under the mental health act. The acting and portrayal of this scary time for the sufferer and family were incredible. I can't comment on any other mental health storylines because I can't remember plus I haven't watched Eastenders in years, thank God. 


THE BAD


Supersize vs. super skinny 

Okay, so this show doesn't explicitly focus on mental health. What it does do, however, is trigger people with eating disorders and in a way it normalises these extreme and unhealthy eating habits. If you've never heard of this show, which I'm sure you have. The premise is two people, one who is very overweight and who is very underweight swap extreme diets to get an insight into how the other person lives.

The massive problem I have with this is this kind of therapy, shock therapy if you like, is that it is not healthy. They both have poor diets, suddenly eating thousands of calories a day or in stark contrast basically fasting for hours on end isn't healthy for anyone. Trust me, I have personal experience of this. What these people need is a balance. A nutritional diet with lots of vitamins and goodness but also a few treats. This show was fuel for my eating disorder when I was younger. I would watch this show feeding the irrational side of my brain pretending that these eating habits were normal and even something to look up to.

TV And Mental Health: The Good The Bad And The Ugly Mental illness blogger uk films TV  the worst obsessive compulsive cleaners depression super size VS superskinny

I'm sure somewhere along the line of the many series' there was they did look at anorexia. The biggest problem I had with this was they were implying these super skinny people they had on the show had eating disorders when they didn't. Someone with an eating disorder might think their terrible eating habits are normal and like I did feed of the numbers and diet inspiration. They also never highlighted binge eating disorder as a mental illness. The overweight people were always just portrayed as being lazy.

Did I mention they also did a child's version of this show which I don't know about you but I find pretty disgusting and just so wrong?


THE UGLY 


Obsessive compulsive cleaners 

OMG, where do I start? I could be here for days ranting about this utter disgrace of a show. It's beyond me how this ever got commissioned. The main idea behind the show was for someone who is an 'obsessive cleaner' to go and clean someone's home which is dirty, vile and disgusting. The main thing which pisses me off about this show is that they have people with and without OCD on there. Some of the obsessive cleaners were clinically diagnosed with OCD who really needed help and support while others were just neat freaks.

They are adding to the stigma that surrounds OCD as they imply all those with OCD, struggle with contamination and germs but that's just not the case at all. They rarely mention any intrusive thoughts or explain how OCD works and keeps sufferers trapped in this vicious cycle. They glamorise mental illness by letting people without OCD show off their impeccably clean homes. Like I'm sorry I don't understand why they have mixed non-sufferers with sufferers it's just confusing and does no good. 

In my opinion, they should have had no OCD sufferers. We're not all obsessed with bacteria and cleanliness! Oh and please don't make it out as if we would happily come around and clean everyone's home because let me tell you there's nothing cute or glamorous about living with OCD. To top it all off the name of this show makes my blood boil. Don't ever use mental illness as acronyms for your jokes. You wouldn't do it about cancer so don't do it about OCD. 

I knew I would get pretty passionate in this post, I'm sorry if I rambled on a bit too much. I'm pretty limited to the TV I can watch as I don't have Netflix or Sky. So if there are any TV shows you watch that do a good or bad job of depicting mental illness, let me know. I would love to find out more.

Thanks for reading, as always X

Check out my May advertisers: Sarah Sapna and Victoria 

Like the blog planner, you see in my photos? Buy it here
SHARE:

10 comments

  1. I've never understood the tv shows that show 'obsessive cleaning' and class it as ocd, its just not and quite frankly its offensive to anybody suffering with the mental illness. Luckily, there are programmes out there that do show mental health/illness how it really is, and to a true representation. I watched a brilliant show the other day called, 'why did i go mad' - all about psychosis, anxiety, depression etcc!

    Lucy | Forever September

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I know! I will never understand it! I will have to check that out

      Delete
  2. I've watched obsessive compulsive cleaners on a few occasions and it did strike me (I'm not even a sufferer of OCD) as a poor portrayal of the illness. I agree that they shouldn't have a mixture of people with and without OCD on there as it sends the message that it's okay to loosely use the term OCD for what is actually just neatness (which a lot of people do anyway - it really annoys me). x

    www.kirstyburrage.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, it is very annoying and does add to the stigma around the illness

      Delete
  3. One thing which many people have been dreaming of always is a fitness body, which rarely is found among people. prohormones for sale

    ReplyDelete
  4. A big round of applause for the amazingly written blog.
    natural laxatives

    ReplyDelete
  5. Gawande's article implies there exists some level of utilization of health care resources that's optimal: use too little and you get mistakes and missed diagnoses; use too much and excess money gets spent without improving outcomes, paradoxically sometimes resulting in outcomes that are actually worse (likely as a result of complications from all the extra testing and treatments).guarantor

    ReplyDelete
  6. In the classic Frank Capra film, It's a Wonderful Life, George Bailey's mental health is overwhelmed by the difficulties of his life and he wishes he'd never been born. George's guardian angel grants his wish and takes him to a grim reality as it would've been without him. guarantor

    ReplyDelete
  7. I will never forget this blog as a perfect work of art.
    atlant gel donde comprar

    ReplyDelete
  8. Such practices, however sparing a couple of bucks may really diminish the effectiveness of the tests by half. There is another perspective worth underscoring in the unique situation; many specialists consider that the most solid tests units for home utilize are those that incorporate specimen accumulation and mail conveyance to a research center. https://stdauthority.com/mission-hills-california-std-testing

    ReplyDelete

Blogger Template Created by pipdig